To address the issues of acquiescence and suggestibility, great care must be taken with the questioning styles used in consultations with a client with intellectual disability.

Although all people are vulnerable to suggestion when being interviewed, people with intellectual disability tend to be more susceptible to the negative consequences of poor questioning (Milne & Bull, 2001). Kebbell et al. (2001) state that two categories of questions frequently used by lawyers can cause problems for witnesses with intellectual disability: (1) questions that communicate the answer required (including yes/no questions, either/or questions and repeated questions), and (2) questions that confuse the witness (including questions with a negative or double negative, multiple questions, and questions with complex vocabulary and sentence structure). They state that ‘all of these unhelpful question types are more likely to be asked by hostile lawyers in cross-examination than by friendly lawyers in evidence-in-chief’. (For more information, see the section: ‘Questioning’.)

Understanding legal terms

Ericson and Perlman (2001) examined the knowledge and understanding of legal terminology used commonly in court proceedings amongst adults with developmental disabilities. They asked the participants to identify which terms they were familiar with and then asked participants to give detail about what they thought the words meant. They found that 75 percent or more of participants with developmental disabilities understood the terms: Court, Jail, Judge, Lawyer, Lie, Police Officer, Truth, Witness.

However, the following terms were not understood by at least 40 percent of participants: Accused, Adjourn, Allegation, Arrest, Case, Charges, Convict, Court Reporter, Crown, Attorney, Defendant, Detective, Evidence, Guilty, Hearing, Interrogate, Objection, Prosecute, Suspect, Swear an Oath, Testimony, Trial, Victim.

The study also found that reporting familiarity with a word was not a reliable indicator of actual familiarity with a word. This is important, because it shows that simply asking ‘do you understand?’ is not a sufficient way of determining a client’s actual level of understanding. It is important to ask clients to explain back in their own words what they understand, and then use that response as a basis to clear up any misunderstanding. The fact that some of the participants were able to provide accurate responses suggests that, if given time and support, people with intellectual disability have the potential to develop deeper understanding of the legal processes affecting them.

In general, questions should be kept as simple and concrete as possible. Abstract questions and concepts should not be used. Ideally, interviewers should consider ways that they can change their own behaviour and adapt their questioning formats to suit the communication needs of the interviewee (Brennan & Brennan, 1994).

Important things to remember when interviewing clients with intellectual disability include:

  • Use plain, simple English 
  • Avoid closed questions 
  • Think before repeating questions: repeating questions may encourage the client to change their answer or to acquiesce. The client may assume that their first answer was wrong and that they should change it (Brennan & Brennan, 1994)
  • Keep questions of choice very simple. Either/or questions tend elicit more reliable responses, because giving too many choices will be more likely to produce a ‘last option bias’. This could be caused by the client’s ‘difficulty in remembering the choice of replies’ (Milne & Bull, 2001) 
  • Avoid multiple questions (for example: ‘As you went into the kitchen, he picked up a knife to defend himself against you? Because you have attacked Adrian in the past, have you not?’). Instead, ask each question separately, and give time for a response to each 
  • Avoid double-barrelled questions 
  • Avoid double negatives.

(For further information, see the section: ‘Questioning’.)

An example of how repeated questioning may encourage someone to acquiesce

Lawyer: Do you remember at your house there used to be shovels kept under the house?

Witness: No.

Lawyer: No shovels?

Witness: There weren’t any shovels.

Lawyer: No shovels at all?

Witness: I don’t think so.

Lawyer: Big long shovels, like this?

Witness: Oh maybe there were some shovels?

Lawyer: Metal?

Witness: Yeah.

Adapted from Kebbell, Hatton, Johnson & O’Kelly, 2001.

Two ladies work around a laptop sitting on a desk.
How are you faring? If you are in the disability sector workforce the WorkAbility Queensland project wants to know what you think, and why you feel the way you do. The project is asking all frontline workers to get involved and take part in the Feelings from the Frontline - Workforce Barometer...
decorative
Queensland Government media release The Palaszczuk Government has stepped in to ensure the Taxi Subsidy Scheme for National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) participants continues over the coming year. Deputy Premier and Treasurer, Jackie Trad, said a further $6 million would be committed in 2019...
decorative
The National Disability Strategy 2010-2020 is about creating a more inclusive society that enables Australians with disability to fulfil their potential as equal citizens. When the strategy ends in 2020, governments across Australia will be working together to develop a new approach for the future...
decorative
Spinal Life Australia is calling on the Queensland Government to extend the Taxi Subsidy Scheme (TSS) for two more years for NDIS participants, with critical funding set to cease on 30 June 2019. With funding ending, more than 10,000 Queensland NDIS participants are projected to no longer have...
decorative
Organisations are invited to apply via an open process for Transition Assistance Funding to purchase tailored supports including business advice, professional services and software upgrades, which will assist to build the disability sector capacity and service provider readiness in the transition...
decorative
The NDIS Quality and Safeguards Commission is a new independent agency established to improve the quality and safety of NDIS supports and services. From 1 July 2019, the NDIS Quality and Safeguards Commission will start managing quality and safeguards in Queensland. They regulate the NDIS market...
The Community Services Peaks all support the goals and principles of the NDIS and have banded together to share peoples NDIS stories and answer key questions about eligibility, signing up and where to go for help. The Community Service Peaks include COTA Queensland, Community Legal Centres...
decorative
Minister for Disability Services Coralee O’Rourke today announced the start of public consultation for the review of the Disability Services Act 2006. “The Disability Services Act 2006 came into effect on 1 July 2006 and is the primary legislation in Queensland governing disability rights, services...
decorative
Queensland Government media release People with a disability using the TransLink Access Pass (TAP) will no longer pay for replacement card charges from August 1. Card expiry dates will be extended from one to five years too, meaning eligible travellers with a permanent disability won’t need to pay...
decorative
Queensland Government media release With the rollout of the NDIS locally from 1 July, Cairns region residents with disability are being encouraged by the Palaszczuk Government to check their eligibility and take up the opportunity to sign up to the scheme. Speaking about the rollout of the NDIS...

Pages

Are you looking for support in Queensland, or trying to find a service that meets your needs? Now you can search oneplace , the service directory hosted by the Queensland Family and Child Commission. oneplace is an easily accessible directory of community services to help Queensland families to get...
Peak organisation for community services organisations supporting people with a disability. www.nds.org.au
Queensland Government web portal with resources to support people with a disablity. www.qld.gov.au/disability
Queensland government departmental website www.communities.qld.gov.au/disability
The Australian Institute of Health and Welfare (AIFW) published Australia's Welfare in October 2017. The report provides an authoritative overview of the wellbeing of Australians, examining a wide range of relevant topics. Read the report here.
Legal Aid have a series of captioned recordings about Legal Aid Queensland services on their YouTube channel . Videos for community, health and education workers can be found here and include their published community legal education webinars. Upcoming webinars can be found on the Information for...
The Queensland Disaster Management website and the Get Ready website have a range of information and useful resources that can assist you to plan and prepare for an emergency. As part of your preparedness and planning for weather events, access regular weather forecast updates from the Bureau of...
To help prepare service providers for the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) the Queensland Government, with support from the Sector Development Fund, has developed tools and resources to support organisations to respond to consumer demand in the NDIS. The project was delivered by the Nous...
The Queensland Government has introduced an online Queensland NDIS events calendar to connect Queenslanders with disability, their families and carers, businesses and service providers with NDIS related events across the state. The new tool allows people to search for events by region or audience (...
Carers Queensland, in collaboration with Queensland Aged and Disability Advocacy (QADA), the Public Trustee, the Office of the Public Guardian and Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT), has launched a series of five new videos to help people better understand advocacy and legal...
The Yarning Circle is a collection of stories about and by Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people with a disability. These stories were produced to provide information about the state-wide Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Disability Network and to start a conversation about the NDIS and...
How to Hear Me is a a resource kit for counsellors and other professionals working with people with intellectual disabilities. It was developed by WWILD Sexual Violence Prevention Association Inc. BROWSE ONLINE: How to Hear Me DOWNLOAD PDF: How to Hear Me
The Complex Communication Needs booklet was produced in an acknowledgement of the impact that skilled communication partners can have on the success of communication. It aims to share information about what the term "complex communication needs" means, the perspectives of some people with complex...
Ramp Up in the ABC's new online destination for news, discussion, debate and humour for everyone in Australia's disability communities. Whether you live with a disability, are a friend or family member of someone with a disability, work in the sector or just want to get a better picture, this is a...
Power of Attorney A power of attorney is a formal document allowing someone else to make decisions on your behalf; both personl and financial. This person can apply for a Domestic Violence Order on the behalf of someone experiencing domestic and family violence. The Powers of Attorney Act 1998...
All service providers operating in Queensland are required to comply with the Queensland Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 . The Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) has jurisdiction to hear and decide complaints about contraventions of this Act. Frequently Asked Questions There are also...
There are a range of legal structures which may be suitable for Queensland not-for-profit community groups. The four main options are: an incorporated association: Associations Incorporation Act 1981 (QLD) and Associations Incorporation Regulation 1999 (QLD) a company limited by guarantee:...
decorative
Author: 
Louise Mullins, Queensland Council of Social Service

Did you know as many as one in five Queenslanders has a disability? Every day, some face barriers to participating in their own community.

Everyone has a role to play in creating a more inclusive Queensland, whether as an individual, through business or as a member of a community group....

decorative
Author: 
Natalie Siegel-Brown, Public Guardian

As the Queensland Public Guardian I am pleased to announce the inaugural opening of the Queensland Public Guardian’s Excellence Awards.

As Public Guardian, I want to acknowledge the exemplary work being undertaken by staff in the community services sector across the...

decorative
Author: 
Sharon Daley, QCOSS

International Day of People with Disability (IDPwD) is held on 3 December each year.

It is a United Nations (UN) sanctioned day, celebrated internationally and aiming to increase public awareness, understanding and acceptance of people with disability, as well as to celebrate the...

Carer helping senior woman
Author: 
Marlene Butteriss, QCOSS

An essential element of person centeredness is to think about issues of power and control. With true person centred approaches, including individualised or self-directed funding models, people with a disability and those who care about them must be the ones that are in control and have authority...

Author: 
Jim Haywood, Centacare Brisbane

At a time of significant disruption in the community services sector, many organisations are rightly focused on defining their inventory and consolidating their market position. The idea of collaboration or partnership in an increasingly competitive market seems nonsensical to many agencies....

Ring of paper children including some in wheelchairs
Author: 
Kristian Schader, Calxa

With the impending roll-out of the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) looming large in Queensland, some Not-For-Profit service providers in the Townsville region are expressing a feeling of isolation and of being somewhat disconnected.

Responding to this need, Calxa...

""
Author: 
Marlene Butteriss, Queensland Council of Social Service

Most people plan life in some way or other. Whether we use paper planners for day to day organisation, plan each month by the moon cycles, or develop a detailed five year plan about meeting goals, people generally have some way of keeping track of what goals they are planning and what steps they...

Author: 
Marlene Butteriss, Queensland Council of Social Service

With so much talk over the last couple of years about people with a disability and their family having more ‘choice and control’ over the supports and services they receive there have been some new terms and concepts introduced like self-direction, self-managed and self-directed funding. Some...

Carer
Author: 
Marlene Butteriss, Queensland Council of Social Service

When talking about how services work with, support and connect with people with a disability, the idea of being ‘person centred’ has been around for a long time. It’s a pretty easy term to understand, but a little harder to put into practice.

Why focus on person centred...

A screenshot of the Care Opinion website
Author: 
Michael Greco, Care Opinion Australia

Care Opinion is an independent, not-for-profit new web site which enables people to post their experiences of local social care services online, and in public (eg aged care, youth and disability care). ...

Pages

See videos from StudioQ related to this topic

Share or Print