Evaluation of the Multi-Tenant Service Centre (MTSC) Pilots Project

Final report prepared for the Department of Communities,
Queensland Government
August 2008 (updated February 2010)

Acknowledgements

I acknowledge and sincerely thank everyone who took part in the evaluation. Thank you to everyone who provided valuable feedback on the case studies, an earlier version of the guidelines included in this report, and other documents. Particular thanks are due to Irene Baker from Inzpire for her detailed feedback on an earlier draft of the two guidelines documents. Some of her suggestions are included in the guidelines presented in this report. Many thanks to all of the participants at the Mackay, Caboolture and Toowoomba Multi-Tenant Service Centre Pilots Project sites. I greatly appreciated your input, feedback and ideas, and the time you gave, especially when you were all so busy. Thanks are also due to all the staff of the Department of Communities staff who provided excellent support, materials, feedback and advice during the evaluation and in the preparation of this report.

Particular thanks go to Michelle McNamara and Debbie Dow in the Mackay office, Brian Smith and Therese Donnelly, formerly in the Caboolture office, Denny Brain in the Toowoomba office, and to the following current and former staff of the Strengthening NGOs Unit/Sector Development Unit in Brisbane: Glenda Sacre, Heidi Trobbiani, Cate Bell, Amanda Shipway and Ken Butler. 

Dr June Lennie
26 August 2009

Executive summary

This report presents learnings, case studies, guidelines and resources for non-government organisations that are planning to implement shared or collaborative arrangements with other agencies. It summarises results from an evaluation of the implementation phase of the Multi-Tenant Service Centre (MTSC) Pilots Project, which was completed in June 2008. This evaluation shows that developing and implementing shared and collaborative arrangements is a complex process that presents many risks, challenges and barriers to success, but can have many potential benefits for non government organisations. As this report makes clear, there is no ‘one size fits all’ approach to this process.

The MTSC Pilots Project was conducted by the Department of Communities (DoC), Queensland Government, as part of its Strengthening Non-Government Organisations strategy. The objective of the MTSC Pilots initiative was to co-locate separate service providers in an appropriately located centre, operating with effective and transparent management, which enabled service providers to improve client services. Three MTSC consortiums in Mackay, Caboolture and Toowoomba were selected as the pilots over a four year period from 2006 – 2010.

Part 1 of this report presents Learnings and Case Studies from the evaluation. The methodology used in the evaluation was user-focused, responsive and collaborative, and used multiple methods, including questionnaires, group discussions, interviews, case studies, and a literature review. The evaluation participants included consortia members and DoC staff in each pilot site and DoC staff in Brisbane.

An overview of models of shared service arrangements is provided. This shows that collaborations between NGOs can include a very wide range of activities and arrangements, from partnerships between large and small NGOs, to full amalgamation or merger. The colocation model has been successfully adopted by a number of not for profit organisations around Australia and overseas. Examples of various co-location models are given.

Case studies of the three pilot projects in Mackay, Caboolture and Toowoomba are then presented. They detail the development of the different collaboration and governance models used in each site, the challenges and issues that emerged, and the strategies used to address them. Each of the co-location models that were developed involved a number of risks, challenges and barriers which included:

  • Managing relationships and other human factors.
  • Reaching agreement on the vision and the collaboration and governance models.
  • Securing adequate funding, support and resources.
  • Sustaining commitment and energy.
  • Managing change and loss of leadership.
  • Managing the building selection, development and design process.
  • Managing communication and information sharing.
  • Negative effects of the establishment process on normal service delivery.

The MTSC concept was clearly not well understood or supported by some local NGOs, and some staff and management committees of the consortiums in the pilot locations. Some pilot project steering committees found it challenging to foster understanding and ownership of the concept, and to encourage others to focus on the ‘big picture’ of cultural change towards collaboration and cooperation, and the long-term benefits they anticipated.

A key issue for each site was the size of the MTSC building, since this dictated the amount of space available and the number of agencies that could be co-located. Differences between the size of the partner agencies was an issue in the Mackay pilot site but not in the other two sites. Some of the factors in the Mackay site included ‘fear of takeover’ and ‘fear of loss of identity’.

Group discussion participants in the pilot sites suggested that, to be most effective and efficient, organisations that are co-locating in a MTSC need to meet the following criteria:

  • Be complementary and have synergies between each other.
  • Have a similar client base and demographics.
  • Not be competing with each other.
  • Have a similar philosophy and a common vision, goals and focus that brings them
  • together.
  • Have a community development focus.
  • Have a community service focus and adopt a client-focussed model of service delivery.
  • The ability to self-evaluate and to shift to a model of sharing information and reflecting on process.

These outcomes were similar to that found in the literature and other case studies. Several benefits from their collaborative arrangements were anticipated by participants in the pilot sites, including:

  • Better accommodation and space.
  • Improved financial savings and ‘economies of scale’.
  • Access to more funding and capacity to take on larger projects.
  • Organisational and governance improvements.
  • Development of a ‘seamless’ referral process.
  • Improved service delivery and client access to services.
  • Increased skills and capacity building of staff and committee members.
  • New or shared knowledge, understanding and learning.
  • Broader perspectives and attitudes.
  • Building strong relationships and linkages and improved support.
  • Stronger capacity to advocate for clients and negotiate with government.

Several of these benefits had already been experienced by the consortiums in the three pilot sites.

In addition to the many sustainability and success factors identified in an earlier literature review (Lennie, 2007), specific success factors identified in the Pilots Project included:

  • Involvement of credible and consistent local departmental staff in some regional areas.
  • The strong commitment of many of those involved.
  • Building good relationships and cooperation between the various parties involved.
  • The active involvement and support of key departmental staff and agencies.
  • Energy, flexibility and ability to embrace the new.
  • When communication was clear and information sharing was effective.
  • Holding visioning workshops, planning at the regional/consortium level, and use of ‘fair’ decision-making processes.
  • Providing resources and training to support the consortiums.

The timeframe for the establishment of the MTSC pilots was much longer than anticipated. Delays in implementing the project created frustration, uncertainty, and loss of energy, commitment and confidence among many consortia members. However, the outcomes of the project show that taking the time to work through the change process during the establishment phase is vital to the success of MTSC initiatives. This requires motivation, strong commitment and leadership, open communication, and the maintenance of good relationships and trust between all those involved.

A significant barrier to small NGOs involved in developing shared service arrangements is the lack of information about how to proceed, the expertise to carry through the change process, and a need for support and guidance (NCOSS, 2007, p.20). Based on learnings from the evaluation and literature review, and feedback on the draft guidelines, Part 2 of this report provides Guidelines and Resources for Establishing Shared and Collaborative Services. These are divided into Guidelines for Non Government Organisations and Guidelines for Project Managers and Coordinators. They include details of the steps in the establishment process, resources, tips, checklists and other practical information that aims to support and assist NGOs, government staff, and others involved in planning and implementing shared and collaborative service initiatives.

AttachmentSize
PDF icon MTSC Evaluation Report Feb 2010415.49 KB
decorative
Health care and social assistance is already the biggest industry in Central Queensland. Planning for further growth requires a deep understanding of local needs and strong and strategic connections between organisations and sectors. The Rockhampton Women's Breakfast will focus on the need for...
decorative
The Queensland Government and the community services industry have co-developed the Partnering for the future: advancing Queensland's services industry 2017-25 strategy as a roadmap for proactively addressing changes and driving collaboration towards the industry's 2025 vision. To help your...
decorative
NDS invites you to this half day workshop, Social Innovation in the NDIS Marketplace , which will focus on developing your organisation’s understanding of key themes in social innovation, and develop your business capability to deliver positive social impact as the sector transitions to an...
decorative
Elections are exciting and offer opportunities for real positive change, but how do you position your organisation to take advantage of these opportunities and avoid the risks? This webinar will discuss campaign and communications case studies from Australia and the UK and help you identify the...
decorative
Pro Bono Australia have launched Civil Voices, a survey to find out the social sector's perspective on the current state of advocacy in Australia. The organisation have said participation in the survey is essential for a holistic insight into the sector's ability to advocate on matters of public...
decorative
Crowdfunding is an increasingly popular method of online fundraising for individuals, businesses, not-for-profits and charities. Generally it involves an individual or an organisation setting a fundraising target online and then asking the crowd of the internet for donations to reach that target...
decorative
The Health and Community Services Workforce Council (Workforce Council) has launched its new project – the Queensland Community Services Workforce Census. This project will collect and analyse previously hidden workforce data across all sub sectors to define job roles across the industry, and the...
Media Statement Minister for Communities, Women and Youth, Minister for Child Safety and Minister for the Prevention of Domestic and Family Violence The Honourable Shannon Fentiman Financial assistance is now available for south-east Queensland’s not-for-profit organisations that have been affected...
decorative
We have launched a brand new course on the Community Door eTraining website which provides an introduction to the social service sector in Queensland for managers and organisations new to the sector. It is free for anyone to access. It features a profile of the sector in Queensland, insights into...
The Brisbane Social Enterprise Meetup Group is run by the peak body, The Queensland Social Enterprise Council, which is a democratically representative organisation promoting social enterprise in Queensland. This meet-up group is a place where social entrepreneurs and supporters of social...

Pages

Are you looking for support in Queensland, or trying to find a service that meets your needs? Now you can search oneplace , the service directory hosted by the Queensland Family and Child Commission. oneplace is an easily accessible directory of community services to help Queensland families to get...
The collaboration decision support tool is designed as a resource to aid organisations considering entering into or forming collaborations to: (a) help to determine if collaboration is the most appropriate model (b) assess current capacity and capability to undertake collaborative action, and (c)...
The Community Resource Handbooks were launched by Volunteering Queensland on 12 May 2015. They consolidate the knowledge gained through Volunteering Queensland's community leadership work with more than 2,000 community groups over the past fifteen years. The handbooks are aimed at small to medium...
Information technology and online solutions can help your community organisation work better. ACOSS, Infoxchange and the Department of Communications have teamed up to bring you Digital Business Kits which give you the tools and information to do more online. Digital Business Kits are hosted on...
In March 2014, QCOSS produced the Rethinking Resources: Case Studies of Financial Resilience from Community Services report, in which community organisations from Queensland share how they are working to increase their financial sustainability. The strategies they employ include social enterprise,...
A series of workshops were held across Victoria in 2008 to investigate community partnerships. Participants strongly reinforced the need for partnerships between community sector organisations and government programs across Victoria to support improved integrated service delivery and enhanced...
This is a very simple and easy to use toolkit that is filled with templates and guides to support your organisation to develop innovative and collaborative ways of working together. From developing a value statement, stakeholder engagement, business planning, SWOT analysis and many more. The...
This conversation explores Western Australia's experience in developing its "Delivering Community Services in Partnership Policy". Rebecca Brown, Deputy Director-General, Department of Premier and Cabinet, Western Australia, Chris Hall, Chief Executive, MercyCare WA and Irina...
This guide looks at client-focused service integration . Options and resources are provided that can assist organisations even without structural change to or between the service providers (government and non-government) involved. Other resources such as the Planned Support Guide provide a case...
This document outlines the the issues and factors you need to think about when working in partnership or merging with other organisations. Download the Collaborative working and mergers document here .
This Research to Practice Note aims to improve understanding of effective interagency collaboration in a shared approach to child protection context and provides a brief overview of the relevant literature in this area. You can access the document here .

Pages

What do you need to succeed?
Author: 
Shelley Dunlop, QCOSS

Community Door hosts a number of useful tools and resources that can assist you with service delivery. These are all free and available for anyone to download. A few of the most popular tools are highlighted here.

...

The Womens Centre Cairns is a proudly feminist not-for-profit organisation that provides services to women and children at risk of domestic violence and homelessness. Drawing funding from the Department of Communities, Child Safety and Disability Services and Department of Housing and Public...

Author: 
Tiffany Tento, Queensland Council of Social Service

National Reconciliation Action Week (27 May to 3 June) is celebrated in Australia each year, in commemoration of two significant milestones in the reconciliation journey – the anniversaries of the successful 1967 referendum and the High Court Mabo decision.

This year’s theme is ...

Author: 
Shelley Dunlop, Queensland Council of Social Service

You may have seen the Network Spaces tab at the top of the Community Door site. You may even think Network Spaces is actually Community Door, a common assumption since the whole of Community Door used to be that green colour.

So what is Network Spaces and why would you want to use it?...

Author: 
The Social Benefit Bond Program, Queensland Treasury

The competitive tender process for the Queensland government's new Social Benefit Bonds program has recently been launched, and the Invitation for Expressions of Interest (EOI) documents are available via...

Author: 
Jim Haywood, Centacare Brisbane

At a time of significant disruption in the community services sector, many organisations are rightly focused on defining their inventory and consolidating their market position. The idea of collaboration or partnership in an increasingly competitive market seems nonsensical to many agencies....

Ring of paper children including some in wheelchairs
Author: 
Kristian Schader, Calxa

With the impending roll-out of the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) looming large in Queensland, some Not-For-Profit service providers in the Townsville region are expressing a feeling of isolation and of being somewhat disconnected.

Responding to this need, Calxa...

Human Rights for Queensland
Author: 
Aimee McVeigh, A Human Rights Act for Queensland

If a government is required to consider human rights while making decisions, a transparent dialogue with the people is created – the people can see their government cares about their rights.

When MP Peter Wellington supported the Labor Party to form government in February, they agreed to...

""
Author: 
Darren Smith, Breaking New Ground

A new chapter in the story of the not-for-profit sector is being drafted. How do small to medium organisations ensure they're written into the script?

The not-for-profit sector has already experienced significant change and uncertainty over the last few years:

  • funding
  • ...
Author: 
Kylie Hogan, National Disability Services

The Community Services Industry is facing a myriad of reforms and challenges now and into the future. 

Challenges such as an ageing population, workforce shortages, sector-wide reforms, technological advances and economic uncertainty are making it more important than ever for...

Pages

See videos from StudioQ related to this topic

Share or Print